Rank RebelsRank Rebels

Guide ยท Rank Rebels University

My Board of Directors: how to run an AI council for big decisions

Short answer: Write one brief. Give it to several assistants, such as Claude, Gemini, ChatGPT, and Meta's Muse, without letting them see each other's answers. Your Chief of Staff bot then writes where they agree, where they split, and a recommended route. You make the final yes or no.

Published .

Four model names feeding one summary, then a final yes or no.ClaudeGeminiChatGPTMuseChief of StaffYou decide
Four assistants answer the same brief. One bot summarizes. You decide.

Why AI councils are a topic right now

Asking several models the same question is no longer a niche trick. Andrej Karpathy's open-source llm-council sends one question to several models, has them review each other's anonymized answers, and asks a chairman model for the final response.

Perplexity built the idea in as Model Council, which reports where models agree, where they disagree, and what each one uniquely surfaces. An October 2026 update moved it into Perplexity Computer as a built-in skill.

People are searching for how to do it themselves. Suggestions for "llm council" include "llm council prompt" and "llm council skill." "ai board of advisors" suggests "ai board of directors prompt" and "ai board of directors app." You do not need special software. You need a good brief, a few assistants, and a clear process. We call it My Board of Directors.

Who sits on the board

Pick three to five assistants from different companies. Models trained by different teams notice different things. That is the point.

Swap in any assistant you already use. Variety matters more than the brand names. Then add one seat that is not a voter: your Chief of Staff bot, which collects the answers and writes the summary. If you do not have one yet, see how to set up an AI Chief of Staff bot with a shared brain.

Walk the decision

Use Next and Back. The steps are the guide. With scripts off, the links still move you through them.

  1. 1. Brief
  2. 2. Council
  3. 3. Summary
  4. 4. You decide

Write one brief

Every member gets the same page: the decision in one sentence, the background, two to four options, the constraints in plain words, and what you want back. Leave out customer names and account details.

Ask Claude, Gemini, ChatGPT, and Muse separately

Paste the brief into each assistant in a fresh chat. Do not show any member the others' answers yet. Independent answers are what make the disagreements useful. Save each answer in your shared notes, labeled by assistant and date.

The Chief of Staff writes the summary

Hand over the brief and all the answers. Ask for the consensus, the disagreements and the reasoning on each side, anything only one member raised, a recommended route with the biggest risk, and the open questions.

You can label the answers A, B, C, and D instead of by name, so the summary weighs the reasoning rather than the brand. Karpathy's project anonymizes answers for this reason.

You make the final yes or no

The board advises. You decide. Read the summary, check any fact that matters against a real source, and choose. Then write one line in the decision log: the date, the decision, the reason, and that the board was consulted.

Log the yes, the reason, and "board consulted." The decision, and the responsibility, stay with you.

Log the no and why. Next time a similar question comes up, the board can read it.

A brief that fits on one page

  1. The decision. One sentence. "Should we add an online version of our service next quarter?"
  2. Background. What the business does, who the customers are, what has been tried.
  3. Options. The two to four routes you are considering.
  4. Constraints. Time, budget limits in plain words, skills, and rules you will not break.
  5. What you want back. A recommendation, the top three risks, what would change their mind, and what they are unsure about.
DECISION: [one sentence]
BACKGROUND: [3-5 sentences]
OPTIONS: A) ... B) ... C) ...
CONSTRAINTS: [time, limits, rules]
PLEASE RETURN:
1. Your recommended option and why
2. The top 3 risks
3. What would change your mind
4. What you are unsure about

When to call the board, and when not to

Good uses: a new offer, a hire, a tool switch, a pricing structure change, a big purchase, a partnership, a messaging rewrite.

Skip the board for quick factual lookups, routine tasks, and anything urgent where one trusted answer is enough. Running four assistants costs usage on each. Save the board for decisions that deserve it. See how to make AI usage last until the limit resets.

Limits to keep in mind

Agreement is not proof. Several models can repeat the same wrong fact. Check anything important. Models change, so keep reviewing which assistant is strongest for which kind of question.

Every member sees the brief. Share only what the decision needs. You own the outcome. The board is advice. The decision, and the responsibility, stay with you.

The AIs advise. You decide.

Rank Rebels is not affiliated with, sponsored by, or endorsed by the makers of the tools named here.

Quick check

Three questions from this guide. Pick an answer for instant feedback. You can also open the answer from the guide if scripts are off.

1. What is an LLM council, in this guide?
Answer from the guide

Several AI models answer the same question independently. Then one model or a person combines the answers and shows the agreements and disagreements.

2. Why ask each assistant in a fresh chat?
Answer from the guide

Do not show any member the others' answers at this stage. Independent answers are what make the disagreements useful.

3. Who makes the final yes or no?
Answer from the guide

Give the answers to the Chief of Staff for a summary. Then make the final call yourself and record why.

FAQ

What is an LLM council?

It is a setup where several AI models answer the same question independently, and then one model or a person combines the answers, showing where they agree and disagree. Karpathy's llm-council and Perplexity's Model Council are two public examples.

Which AI models should be on my AI board of directors?

Choose three to five assistants from different companies, such as Claude, Gemini, ChatGPT and Meta's Muse. Variety helps, because different models often catch different risks.

How do I combine answers from multiple AI models?

Give all the answers and the original brief to one assistant acting as Chief of Staff, and ask it for the consensus, the disagreements, unique points and a recommended route. Then make the final call yourself.

Should AI make business decisions for me?

No. Use AI to widen what you consider and to surface risks, then make the decision yourself and record why.

Build your own Board of Directors

Rank Rebels University shows you how to set up a Chief of Staff bot, write board briefs, and run your own AI council for the decisions that matter.

Enroll in Rank Rebels University

Sources